Telling the stories that the mainstream media no longer tell.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 14 other subscribers

Archives

Categories

Follow me on Twitter

March 2017
M T W T F S S
« Mar    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

OMSI Has Egg On Its Face – Excludes Peer Reviewed Science From Climate Conference

galileo mob

What an interesting follow up we have today to last weekend’s canceled climate conference at OMSI.

The reader will recall that OMSI canceled, at the last minute, the Oregon American Meteorological Society’s event featuring Meteorologist Chuck Wiese, Climatologist George Taylor, and Gordon Fulkes, PhD, on November 29 due to the inclusion of AGW skeptics on the agenda.

Reaction is pouring in from scientists all around the world, and several AMS members are canceling their memberships over this matter.

One gentleman replied to the email announcement from Dr. Fulkes:

What? Really???

No room for an alternate point of view at OMSI? Orthodoxy instead of a fair and objective hearing of ideas? This is disgraceful. Whoever made the decision to cancel the AMS meeting ought to be fired on grounds of disrespect for science.

I have volunteered at OMSI in the past. I won’t be doing that in the future.

I have, by the way, a Ph.D. in Computer Science and what I consider to be very good reasons for being skeptical about the results of the computer models that underlie the claim that human-generated CO2 is causing global warming.

Please forward these comments to OMSI’s High Priest of the Reigning Dogma (i.e. the imperial authority who made this bad and unscientific decision).

Dr. Fulkes has provided some further detail in his reply:

Apparently one of the excuses that OMSI gave to the AMS was that they did not approve of anything less than peer-reviewed science being presented at OMSI.  That is especially ironic because they permitted the AMS Winter Weather Conference to go ahead which did not feature ANY peer-reviewed science.

And I was going to begin my talk on November 29 with a discussion of the peer-reviewed science that I have done that forms the foundation for some of the most exciting things happening in real climate science: the cosmic ray – cloud  connection of Henrik Svensmark.  That is, of course,  peer-reviewed science too.  One of my professors (the great Astrophysicist Eugene Parker) was partially responsible for forcing one of the major scientific journals to take a serious look at the high quality work coming from the Danish Space Research Institute and Svensmark.  Svensmark also has the support of the brilliant Israeli Astrophysicist Nir Shaviv.

But the people at OMSI took the word of someone from PSU who apparently claimed that we were not competent scientists!  I agree that that person should be fired for failing to exercise due diligence and for failing to have ANY respect for the scientific discussions that are so necessary in real science.

Climate science that cannot be discussed is not science at all.  OMSI should at least be able to understand that.  I hope.

Now, let me focus on one point here that I found striking in its arrogance:

Apparently one of the excuses that OMSI gave to the AMS was that they did not approve of anything less than peer-reviewed science being presented at OMSI.  That is especially ironic because they permitted the AMS Winter Weather Conference to go ahead which did not feature ANY peer-reviewed science. 

And I was going to begin my talk on November 29 with a discussion of the peer-reviewed science that I have done …

This is quite possibly the most insulting treatment you could give an internationally famous PhD who has devoted his life to finding the truth through the scientific method. To be so dismissive of such an esteemed researcher reveals blatant elitism. Dr. Fulkes also reveals the source of the reconsideration – a professor at Portland State who raised some sort of objection based on heresay and a failure by Dr. Fulkes to prostrate himself to the AGW cultists.

OMSI has shown itself in this process to be against the scientific method and real research when it does not fit their agenda. This, then, makes it a political decision. I wonder how that affects their tax-exempt status as a 501(c)(3) non-profit?

Postscript: Let’s see how long it takes The Oregonian to pick up on this story.

 

Similar posts

4 Comments

  1. Kozlowski's Gravatar Kozlowski
    November 29, 2011    

    “But the people at OMSI took the word of someone from PSU who apparently claimed that we were not competent scientists! ”

    Does PSU stand for Penn State University? The very same place where Michael Mann sent his now infamous emails (released in Climategate 2.0) trying to get skeptics shut down?

    From my recollection of reading the climategate 2.0 emails, Mann used the exact same methods, claiming that the scientists were not competent, that they were motivated by politics and were funded by oil companies.

  2. jabber00's Gravatar jabber00
    November 30, 2011    

    I don’t think talking of people being fired is sensible. Isn’t this similar to the actions taken by “the team” and their hangers on in the cases of Chris de Freitas and later Baulinas and Soon and which this and other blogs have criticised.

    • November 30, 2011    

      jabber00, that all depends on whether this affects the museum’s tax exempt status as a nonprofit. If that has been compromised, heads will roll.

No Pings Yet

  1. The More OMSI Digs, The Deeper It Gets « 54°40′ Or Fight! on November 28, 2011 at 8:36 pm
  2. OMSI, Global Warming and the Bunker Mentality – Silence in the Face of Public Criticism « 54°40′ Or Fight! on December 3, 2011 at 3:12 pm
  3. Year End Climate Hysteria News – Interactive Map of Hysteria! « 54°40′ Or Fight! on December 26, 2011 at 10:41 pm
  4. AGW – More “Unsettled Science” | The GOLDEN RULE on January 17, 2012 at 8:19 pm
  5. Cancelled November Global Warming Meeting at OMSI Rescheduled for January 25 « 54°40′ Or Fight! on January 22, 2012 at 10:59 pm

This site sponsored by:

YOU! Your message could reach thousands of online consumers. Click CONTACT to inquire about advertising rates.

Paid advertisement

  • Seattle Mayor Ed Murray responds to Sessions’ call to pull federal grant money from ‘sanctuary cities’ March 27, 2017
    U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions told municipalities Monday, that if they did not comply with federal immigration laws, he would seek to withdraw federally funded grants from refusing municipalities. As part of his statement, he said: Today I am urging all states and local jurisdictions to comply with all federal laws, including 8 U.S.C. Section 1373. […]
  • House Democrats propose budget with revenue gained through capital gains excise tax March 27, 2017
    An earlier version of this story incorrectly referred to the budget in terms “millions” instead of “billions.” House Democrats explained Monday how they plan to bring in sufficient revenue to meet the Legislature’s Constitutional obligation to fully fund education. The price tag on Democrats’ proposed budget is $44.8 billion. Last week, the Republican-led Senate proposed […]
  • Washington responds to House pulling the AHCA March 24, 2017
    Speaker of the House Paul Ryan conceded Friday that there are not enough votes to pass the American Health Care Act through his chamber. Ryan needed 216 votes to pass the legislation that would repeal the Affordable Care Act and replace it with a system of flat tax credits dispersed to residents based on age, […]
  • Cincinnati Streetcars’ “Catastrophic Failures” March 28, 2017
    The Cincinnati streetcar–now known as the Cincinnati Bell Connector since Cincinnati Bell paid $3.4 million for naming rights–is barely six months old, and already is having problems. Four streetcars broke down in one day a few months ago. Now the company that is contracted to operate the streetcar has warned that poor quality control by […]
  • Property Bubbles Down Under? March 27, 2017
    In an eerie echo of statements made before the collapse of American housing bubbles in 2006, leading Australian bankers claim that Australia is not suffering a housing bubble. Yet prices are unsustainably high and a collapse is inevitable, though when it will happen may be unpredictable. Median home prices in Sydney are AU$795,000 (US$606,000). More […]
  • Backstabbing in the Self-Driving Car Industry March 24, 2017
    Bloomberg has a long article about Google’s lawsuit against Uber over self-driving car technology. In a nutshell, one of Google’s top engineers, Anthony Levandowski, left Google to start a new company called Otto that was then purchased by Uber for $700 million, and Google is accusing Levandowski of taking its company secrets with him and […]