Telling the stories that the mainstream media no longer tell.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 4,030 other subscribers

Archives

Categories

Follow me on Twitter

September 2017
M T W T F S S
« Mar    
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

The Oregonian and PolitiFact – Bending Over Backward Not To Give A Republican Credit

pants on fire

PolitiFact has just submitted another entry in a long line of evidence of bias in their analysis.

This time, it’s the Oregonian’s man on the beat, Charles Pope.

Mr. Pope has decided to dissect this statement on the website of Oregon’s only Republican Congressman, Greg Walden:

“When the bill was signed into law, the White House promised that the stimulus would increase by 44,000 the number of jobs in Oregon by December 2010,” he says on his official congressional website. “Unfortunately, even with the stimulus, since the bill was signed, the number of jobs has actually decreased by 18,300 through July 2011.”

Now, this seems like a pretty straightforward statement, easily confirmed. Heck, it doesn’t even seem like an overly political statement, especially given some of the extreme rhetoric emanating from both sides of the aisle.

Would you believe it took Mr. Pope 928 words to complete his dissection, and he found a way to label this statement only Half True?

It’s True (to coin a phrase). One might think the post would end with this:

Walden supports his claim with a study by the Republican staff of the House Ways and Means Committee. That study relies on federal statistics and, sure enough, both the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics and the Oregon Employment Department show that Oregon had fewer people working in July 2010 than February 2009.

When the stimulus was signed into law in February 2009, 1.643 million people in Oregon held non-farm jobs, according to the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics. In July 2010, after billions of dollars of stimulus spending had been dispersed, the number of non-farm jobs in Oregon was 1.625 million.

That’s a loss of 18,000 jobs which is the number Walden cited.

Unfortunately, we’re only about 1/3 of the way through the article at this point. (Charles, I said “about”, so that’s gotta be at least Partly True.)

The rest of the article consists of several analyses and citations, all of which pretty much say something like this:

The most recent came Nov. 22 from the Congressional Budget Office. It says the stimulus is responsible for adding between 500,000 and 3.3 million jobs nationally.

But the CBO, which is nonpartisan, also says its reports, “do not provide a comprehensive estimate of the law’s impact on U.S. employment, which could be higher or lower…”

Among the reasons is that “some of the jobs included in the reports might have existed even without the stimulus,” and that the reports do not “attempt to measure” the number of indirect jobs.

So, The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act was inherently imprecise, and as we all remember, the target quickly changed from “jobs created” to “jobs created or saved”. Estimates of jobs “created or saved”, as cited by Mr. Pope himself, range from 500,000 to 3.3 million nationwide. Statistically speaking, that’s a tad outside the margin of error. Mathematicians call that difference “an order of magnitude”.

So let’s summarize. Republican Congressman Walden has a precise statement on his website that is backed up by the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics, the Oregon Employment Department, the Congressional Ways and Means Committee and the CBO. Reporter/analyst Charles Pope agrees that the figure is correct and unassailable by fact. Mr. Pope subsequently does a bunch of research trying to refute this statement, and because of the murky nature of The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, the only logical conclusion is that Congressman Walden must also be murky and therefore gets a grade of Half True.

Charles Pope, we hereby grade your PolitiFact hit piec … err … analysis as Pants On Fire.

Similar posts

No Comments Yet

This site sponsored by:

YOU! Your message could reach thousands of online consumers. Click CONTACT to inquire about advertising rates.

Paid advertisement

  • Washington state House Democrats ask Congress to find a solution to keep DACA recipients here September 22, 2017
    This week, all 50 members of the Washington state House Democratic Caucus sent a letter to Speaker Ryan and Majority Leader McConnell requesting that Congress take action in response to President Trump’s decision to rescind the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. Washington state is home for nearly 18,000 young people who are able to […]
  • Morning Wire: Reichert for Gov?, Seattle Seahawks, Rep. Joe Schmick September 20, 2017
    The purpose of the Washington State Wire is to provide smart, strategic content with thoughtful brevity. We create original content, and we lean on the good work of others. We see our role as helping you look ahead just a little bit, to better know where the policy, political, and economic landscape is heading. Your […]
  • Public policy, the will of the voters, and the Seattle Seahawks September 19, 2017
    “Across all demographics, the 12s are contagious. It’s for everybody.” In this quote, King County Council member Jeanne Kohl-Welles was reflecting on the role of the Seattle Seahawks as a unifying force for the Seattle community. It may be hard to remember for some, particularly the new fans that winning has recruited over the last […]
  • Trump Praises Dallas Cowboys for Standing During National Anthem: ‘Big Progress Being Made’ September 26, 2017
    President Donald Trump praised the Dallas Cowboys Tuesday for rising for the national anthem before their Monday night game against the Arizona Cardinals. The post Trump Praises Dallas Cowboys for Standing During National Anthem: ‘Big Progress Being Made’ appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.
  • Jackson Lee Takes a Knee September 26, 2017
    The post Jackson Lee Takes a Knee appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.
  • State Medicaid Adviser Says Graham-Cassidy Bill Will Stabilize Marketplace September 26, 2017
    A state Medicaid adviser told lawmakers on Monday that the Graham-Cassidy bill to replace Obamacare would stabilize the health care marketplace by combining Medicaid populations with younger, healthier individuals. The post State Medicaid Adviser Says Graham-Cassidy Bill Will Stabilize Marketplace appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.
  • Black Population Trends September 25, 2017
    Between 2015 and 2016, the total population of the San Francisco-Oakland urban area grew by 13,773 people, but the black population shrank by 5,839, suggesting that Bay Area land-use policies continue to push low-income people out of the region by making housing unaffordable. The Austin urban area, to its shame, saw a decline of 4,439 […]
  • More 2016 Commuting Data September 22, 2017
    People who earn more than $75,000 a year are more likely to ride transit than people in any other income bracket. Most of those high-income transit riders live not in big cities like New York or Chicago but in suburbs of those cities. That information is from table B08119 from the 2016 American Community Survey. […]
  • Housing Affordability in 2015 September 22, 2017
    Today the Antiplanner continues reviewing 2016 American Community Survey data by looking at housing affordability, a common measure of which is median house prices divided by median family incomes, or value-to-income ratio. Median family incomes are in ACS table B19113, while median home prices are in table B25077. To save you time, I’ve downloaded these […]